Jeff shaara is the new york times bestselling author of a chain of thunder, a blaze of glory, the final storm, no less than victory, the steel wave, the rising tide, to the last man, the glorious cause, rise to rebellion, and gone for soldiers, as well as gods and generals and the last full measuretwo novels that complete the civil war trilogy that began with his fathers pulitzer prize. More seriously from the standpoint of historical accuracy, the 54th. Mar 10, 2003 gods and generals is based on a best selling book by jeff shaara. May 28, 1996 gods and generals is a prequel to that book, covering the leadup to the civil war, plus the first two years of the war. Jeff shaara continued his fathers legacy with a series of centuriesspanning new york times bestsellers. Gods and generals is a novel which serves as a prequel to michael shaaras 1974 pulitzer prizewinning work about the battle of gettysburg, the killer angels. In defense of my movie, gods and generals history news. Doesnt matter if you ever see the movie, this soundtrack will grab you and hold on. Indeed, cold mountain can be viewed as the anti gods and generals. Sign me up to get more news about historical fiction books. The historical accuracy of the movies portrayal of jackson. Had washington not attempted the crossing of the icechoked delaware river and had the illfed, freezing, poorly trained, and poorly armed continentals failed to prevail over the feared hessian mercenaries, the american revolution would probably have collapsed. Indeed, although the movie is based on the historical novel of the same name by.
The best thing about this book is that it allows the readers to get to know the soldiers, how each of the generals struggled with fear and hoped for a better life after. Jeff shaara goes deeper and explores the personal conflicts of four historical figures, two from the south and two from north. Through the eyes of winfield scott hancock and joshua chamberlain we see the ineptitude of the union leadership and the frustration of losing the first major battles of the war. This film is historically accurate, deeply moving, and with outstanding acting by all. The central character of gods and generals is the remarkable confederate general, thomas jonathan stonewall jackson.
Gods and generals is a prequel to that book, covering the leadup to the civil war, plus the first two years of the war. Ken burns, on the killer angels the last full measure is more than another historical novel. The deeper truth of gods and generals seems to be that the war was the souths second war of independence, as robert duvalls robert e. A novel of the civil war by jeff shaara is the first novel in an american civil war trilogy, written from several viewpoints of civil war characters. Gods and generals is good hollywood dont go see it. Lee turning down an appointment to lead the union army to the battle. Lee was shown throughout the movie as wearing the three star insignia of a colonel, rather than the three stars surrounded by a wreath as was the proper insignia for all confederate generals.
Gods and generals, based on the bestselling book by jeff shaara, is such a movie. Gods and generals and the last full measure are based on novels and. From wikipedia, the free encyclopedia gods and generals is a 2003 american period war drama film written and directed by ronald f. Ron maxwell, author and director, gods and generals. The film, much like the book, adopted a prosouthern lost cause ideology, which is the belief that the war for the confederacy was doomed from the. Gods and generals focuses on the men who shaped the early part of the american civil war through the different points of view from both the union and confederate sides. Maxwell urged jeff shaara to trade his vocations of general contractor and coin collector in middle age, and try writing, taking up where his. The new york times bestselling prequel to the pulitzer prizewinning classic the killer angels. In defense of my movie, gods and generals history news network. Official artist of gods and generals to sign prints, books.
Historical accuracy seems to be lacking in most hollywood films about any time period. Instead, it is merely a good portrait of stonewall jackson, surrounded by a bad movie. It tells the powerful story of the most important event in the history of the united states in an accurate. Gods and generals is american history transformed into a museum movie, consistently making the flawed human characters at the heart of the. Kaufen sie gettysburg gods and generals gunstig ein. War, for exampleand think historical accuracy is a virtue instead of an. In gods and generals many of the characters talk like, well, someone from the midnineteenth century south would talk. Gods and generals is a novel which serves as a prequel to michael shaaras 1974 pulitzer. The civil war trilogy 3book boxset gods and generals, the. Gods and generals the society for military history. Based on jeff shaaras book of the same title, gods and generals accounts for the events leading up to the war as well as early battles at bull run, fredericksburg and chancellorsville. Gods and generals by jeffrey shaara is a novel in the historical fiction.
Chicago turabian humanities citation style guide shaara, jeff, 1952 and michael. Aug 15, 2003 gods and generals is part of a growing movement that seeks to rewrite the history of the american south, downplaying slavery and the economic system that it sustained. In gods and generals many of the characters talk like, well, someone. In museums, schools and city council chambers, white neoconfederates are hard at work in an effort to have popular memory trump historical accuracy. It takes place during the american civil war, and the book features four protagonists. Gods and generals is a 2003 american period war drama film written and directed by ronald f. However, the end result of gods and generals was completely the opposite. General lee, general jackson, colonel chamberlain, and hancock. Mar 03, 2003 with gods, maxwell tries to tell dozens of stories that take place over the span of about three years, and he winds up failing on nearly all fronts.
Michael shaara reinvented the war novel with his pulitzer prizewinning masterpiece of gettysburg, the killer angels. Just like the killer angels, this novel is character driven narrative based on the detailed facts of the american civil war. Gaining wide currency in the 19th century, the lost cause interpretation remains remarkably persistent even today as gods and generals illustrates. Gods and generals the more you know about the civil war, the more youll appreciate gods and generals and the painstaking attention to detail that gettysburg writerdirector ronald f. Many books have been written on this first modern war describing how over 620,000 men were killed. Maxwell has invested in this academically respectable 220minute historical pageant. On a smaller note, the soundtrack to this film is fantastic better than. Gods and generals a journey to the past ron maxwell. Much is made of the films total and obsessive historical accuracy. It tells the powerful story of the most important event in the history of the united states in an accurate and faithhonoring way. The book adopts the same approach as the killer angels, recounting events from the perspective of several key figures, in this case primarily lee, hancock, jackson, and chamberlain. Michael shaara here is thomas stonewall jackson, a hopelessly bythe book military instructor and devout christian. A native of new jersey, michael shaara grew to be an adventurous young man. Gods and generals is a personalized historical book.
His fierce exterior hides a compassionate soul that few students and soldiers alike will. This is the question that haunts gods and generals, jeff shaaras moving novel of the early. Chicago turabian author date citation style guide shaara, jeff, 1952 and michael. Gods and generals is american history transformed into a museum movie, consistently making the flawed human characters at the heart of the civil war into flawless figures olympian in their.
San francisco chronicle, on gods and generals remarkable. Although it is based on a novel, gods and generals focuses on wellknown historical figures. Lee describes the forthcoming conflict as he accepts command of virginias forces in 1861. Its emotional without ever being in your face, as some epic orchestrations. In this brilliantly written epic novel, jeff shaara traces the lives, passions, and careers of the great military leaders from the first gatheri.
It is an adaptation of the 1996 novel of the same name by jeffrey shaara and prequel to maxwells 1993 film gettysburg. Gods and generals, based on the best selling book by jeff shaara, is such a movie. General lee actually wore this throughout most if not all of the war, and this is accurate. Epic gods and generals tilts genteelly to the south. A companion history to the motion picture of the same name, gods and generals is based on the bestselling jeff shaara novel, and surveys a crucial period in a companion history to the motion picture of the same name, gods and generals is based on the bestselling jeff shaara novel, and surveys a crucial period in the war between the states. G ods and generals by jeff shaara is the prequel to his late fathers pulitzer prizewinning novel the killer angels. I had never visited gettysburg, knew almost nothing about that battle before i read the book, but here it all came alive. Gods and generals runs almost four hours, including an intermission. While gettysburg had a southern slant, that could be excused as an accurate rendering of the source novel and the fact that the confederate. Ronald maxwell, director of the movie gettysburg, which was based on michael shaaras the killer angels, was the prime instigator of the younger shaaras efforts toward his new novel.
The magnificent new movie gods and generals raises a related issue. In rallying his shaken troops, bee launches the name of stonewall into history and the. On the side of the confederate army are thomas jonathan jackson and robert e. Gods and generals should have been a rich opportunity to explore the bonds of religious belief and war with a backdrop of the most troubled time in u. Gods and generals opening titles with mary fahls going. Shaara has learned an impressive amount of facts about the men and events his.
Read the civil war trilogy 3 book boxset gods and generals, the killer angels, and. About the civil war trilogy 3 book boxset gods and generals, the killer angels, and the last full measure. Gods and generals 2003 cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. The rise and fall of confederate general thomas stonewall jackson, as he meets with military success against the union from 1861 to 1863, when he is accidentally killed by his own soldiers. Gods and generals goodreads meet your next favorite book. As dry as a high school history book, solemn as a funeral service, humorless as a politburo meeting, bloated as a waterlogged corpse and unbalanced as a bout between a debutante and a sumo wrestler. Together at last in ebook form, this volume assembles three.
The film plays like a special issue of american heritage. When they wanted to do so, the makers of gods and generals were accurate in. This film is a dramatization of washingtons victory at trenton the day after christmas, 1776. Feb 21, 2003 gettysburg was maxwells adaptation of the killer angels, the pulitzer prizewinning historical novel by michael shaara.
Neoconfederates attempt to whitewash southern history. The battle scenes in gods and generals are its high points. Internationally acclaimed historical painter mort kunstler, the official artist for the movie gods and generals, will visit virginia tech on saturday, march 1, 11 a. Written by jeffrey shaara after his father michaels death in 1988, the novel relates events from 1858 through 1863 during the american civil war, ending just as the two armies march toward gettysburg. November 14, 2003 today i watched gods and generals for the first time. With stephen lang, robert duvall, jeff daniels, donzaleigh abernathy. It will soon come to life as a maxwell film by the same name. It stars stephen lang as stonewall jackson, jeff daniels as lieutenant colonel joshua chamberlain and robert duvall as general robert e. Gods and generals by jeffrey shaara is a novel in the historical fiction genre. The problem for gods and generals as history is that the first part of the lost cause argument is demonstrably false. War, for exampleand think historical accuracy is a virtue instead of an attribute. Gods and generals bob dylan cross the green mountain music video warner bros. The civil war trilogy 3book boxset gods and generals. As gettysburg was based on the historical novel the killer angels 1974 by michael shaara, so gods and generals is based on the 1998 historical novel of that title written by shaaras son jeff.
Shaara intended the book as a prequel to the killer angels, a civil war classic about the battle of gettysburg written by. Both lee and stephen langs stonewall jackson give voice to certain clear views. As a result, character interactions function as debates and lectures on civil war history, while relationships rarely register as authentic. Feb 21, 2003 one of the problems with historical accuracy is that it can spread like kudzu. Gods and generals, ted turner and ron maxwells followup to 1993s gettysburg, wants to be a quintessential civil war epic. Gods and generals what did not work nonfiction history.
Gods and generals and the proposed final chapter the last full measure were inspired via the unique flipflopped circumstance of a film director being the catalyst to inspire a bestselling novel. It is an adaptation of the 1996 novel of the same name by jeffrey shaara and. The last full measure, also written by shaara, completes the civil war trilogy. The soundtrack is notable for containing a new song commissioned. Although jeff had never penned a book, he took on the challenge of writing gods and generals. May 24, 2011 the dialogue in gods and generals should serve as a lesson to budding filmmakers in the dangers of exposition. They have the same virtues as the war scenes in gettysburg. The new york times bestselling prequel to the pulitzer prizewinning classic the killer angels in this brilliantly written epic novel, jeff shaara traces the lives, passions, and careers of the great military leaders from the first gathering clouds of the civil war. Rarely does a big budget hollywood movie come along that reflects history and the christian faith of the protagonists in an historical event accurately and faithfully. The conversations seem directed at the audience more than at characters in the film. Gods and generals is the kind of movie beloved by people who never go to the movies, because they are primarily interested in something elsethe civil war, for exampleand think historical accuracy is a virtue instead of an attribute. Gods and generals is a novel which serves as a prequel to michael shaara s 1974 pulitzer prize winning work about the battle of gettysburg, the killer angels. Overall, gods and generals is a fine piece of civil war fiction. A worth tribute, gods and generals by jeff shaara cwt.
Historians reaction to gods and generals part 1 youtube. This is the complete screenplay for gods and generals plus historical background, biographies, archival illustrations, behindthescenes photographs, and details. Gods and generals, a faithfilled epic baptist press. Slavery, not states right, was both the proximate and deep cause of the war. D in military history from the ohio state university in 1997 and is currently an associate professor of history at buena vista university in storm lake, iowa. The soundtrack is notable for containing a new song com.
Read the civil war trilogy 3book boxset gods and generals, the killer angels, and. First of all, it is long, timing out at almost four hours. This is a prequel for the pulitzer prize winning book the killer angels by michael shaara, the authors father. Long awaited by both historians and buffs, the film gods and generals is a prequel to the 1993 film gettysburg. As gettysburg was based on the historical novel the killer angels 1974 by. It had been recommended to me about a half a year ago by a dear friend.
1271 1017 981 1877 421 267 906 472 1813 1292 585 258 461 1285 197 1636 597 1326 774 742 191